Which rental property earns more for the same costs?
$100
This week: replace both rents and expense lines with numbers from two real listings.
| Property | Price | Cash flow | CoC return | Gross rental yield | Price/SqFt | Rent ratio | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Property A | $300,000 | $100 | 2.00% | 9.60% | $167 | 0.80% | 57/100 |
Property B | $425,000 | -$300 | -4.24% | 9.04% | $177 | 0.75% | 25/100 |
Scoring system (0-100):
Key metrics:
Written by Elizabeth Stein
With monthly rent of $2,400 and entered expenses of $2,300, which include the mortgage payment, the tool shows $100 a month. Raise the expenses to $2,700 and it falls to minus $300. Costs omitted from the inputs are also omitted from the result.
Finance Quest is educational. It is not financial advice, and no calculator here knows your full situation.
The comparison can only use the expenses you enter. A higher displayed cash flow may reflect missing costs rather than a better property. Apply the same expense assumptions to each property.
No. This page compares rental investment properties. It does not model renting your own home against owning it.
The score combines fixed thresholds for cash flow, cash-on-cash return, gross rental yield, rent-to-price ratio, and property age. It compares the entered examples, but it does not account for local market conditions, property condition, or your circumstances.
No. Use the mortgage calculator to explore payments, then include applicable financing costs in monthly expenses here.